OEE works on a manual process when the task repeats, the output can be counted and the station has a fixed crew. Use (good units x ideal time per unit) / scheduled time, with the ideal taken from the best proven rate for that crew size. If people move between jobs all day or every unit is different, use a labor metric instead.
When the machine is a person
Hand packing, kitting, manual assembly and final inspection have no spindle and no PLC. The OEE arithmetic still works, because a station has a schedule, a rate and a good count.
The difference is that "speed" now means human pace. That makes the rules around the number matter more than they do on a filler.
Does OEE fit your manual process?
Start here, because on some manual work OEE is the wrong tool. A forced number will mislead you and annoy the crew.
| Type of work | OEE fit | What to use |
|---|---|---|
| Same task, fixed station or cell, countable output | Good | OEE per station or cell |
| Manual stations feeding a machine line | Partial | Line OEE, with blocked and starved time pointing at the manual stations |
| People move across several jobs in a shift | Weak | Units per labor hour |
| One-off work, repairs, work content changes per unit | Poor | Plan attainment against the quoted hours |
What changes on a manual station
A stop or just a slow moment?
A machine can tell you it stopped, and a person cannot. So decide what a stop is in plain words: the station cannot work, or nobody is there to work it while work is planned.
- Stops: no parts, no packaging, missing instructions, a tool out of service, a crew pulled to another area.
- Not stops: reaching for a part, turning a box, wiping a surface. Those belong inside the cycle.
- Excluded: planned breaks, if that is your site rule.
Pick a short limit, such as 2 minutes, below which a pause shows up as slow running instead of a logged stop. Setting the stop threshold explains the trade-off.
Where a crew's ideal comes from
Use the best rate the crew has proven with good quality, at normal effort and with the full crew. How to find the ideal run rate shows the method.
Be careful with a standard time from a time study. It usually adds allowances to the basic time, so the rate it implies can be slower than a good crew holds, and performance climbs over 100%.
The first-pass count
A good unit passes the first time. A kit that gets opened and fixed at the end of the bench is not good on the first count, even though it ships.
The crew-size question
This is the part that machine guides skip. A cell can run with 4 people on Monday and 3 on Tuesday, and that changes the rate you can expect.
You have two honest choices. They give different numbers, and each answers a different question.
Worked example: a hand-pack cell
Example: a kitting cell has 450 scheduled minutes and logs 60 minutes of stops, so run time is 390 minutes. The proven rate is 2 kits a minute with 4 people and 1.5 with 3.
For 300 run minutes the cell had 4 people and made 540 kits, with 15 rejected. For the last 90 minutes it had 3 people and made 120 kits, with 5 rejected.
| Item | Fixed ideal (4 people always) | Crew-scaled ideal |
|---|---|---|
| Ideal minutes for all kits made | 660 x 0.5 = 330.0 | (540 x 0.5) + (120 / 1.5) = 350.0 |
| Ideal minutes for good kits | 640 x 0.5 = 320.0 | (525 x 0.5) + (115 / 1.5) = 339.2 |
| Availability | 390 / 450 = 86.7% | 390 / 450 = 86.7% |
| Performance | 330 / 390 = 84.6% | 350 / 390 = 89.7% |
| Quality | 320 / 330 = 97.0% | 339.2 / 350 = 96.9% |
| OEE | 320 / 450 = 71.1% | 339.2 / 450 = 75.4% |
We suggest the fixed ideal for the headline number. A short crew costs output, and hiding it inside a lower target means nobody asks why the cell ran short.
Then log the shortage by name, as in waiting for operator. Keep the crew-scaled figure for judging how well the people present actually worked.
How to measure it on the floor
Keep the first version cheap, since you are testing the rules and not the hardware. Paper is fine for a month, and the OEE tracking template gives you a sheet to start from.
- Count: finished units at the last step. A part-counting sensor or scan at pack-out beats end-of-shift memory.
- Stops: a stop-start button or a tally by reason.
- Crew: write down the headcount per hour. Without it, you cannot explain a slow afternoon.
- Rhythm: an hour-by-hour board shows when the day slipped while there is still time to act.
Mistakes specific to manual work
- Scoring individuals. OEE belongs to the station. Use it to rank people, and the logging soon turns dishonest.
- One ideal for every product. A 12-part kit and a 3-part kit need their own times, then add good minutes across products.
- Treating stops as slow pace. A person waiting for parts is a supply problem, and a low performance number blames the wrong thing.
- Chasing pace first. Waiting, missing parts and rework are usually easier to fix than asking people to move faster, and safer too.
- Comparing with machine lines. A manual cell and an automated filler have different loss patterns. Compare each with its own past.
What to do next
Run the fit test above for one station, then write the stop rule and the ideal rate on one page. Track two weeks before you discuss the number with anyone.
Enter the first shift into the OEE calculator to check your arithmetic. If most of the loss turns out to be waiting, the fix lies upstream of the cell.
Manual stations rarely have a PLC to read. Where cameras are fitted, Fabrico shows video of a stop, streamed on request next to its machine data, and operators tag the cause at the line. See how Fabrico handles cameras and stops.
What people ask next
Can you calculate OEE without a machine?
Yes, if the work repeats and the output can be counted. The station takes the place of the machine, and the formula stays good units x ideal time / scheduled time. The OEE calculator works the same way for a hand-pack cell.
Should I use OEE or OLE for manual work?
Use OEE when you want to know how well a station used its scheduled time. Use OLE, overall labor effectiveness, when the question is how well paid hours became good output, especially when crew sizes change. Units per labor hour is a simple labor measure to start with.
How do I set the ideal time for a manual task?
Take the best rate the full crew has proven with good quality, at normal effort. Avoid using a standard time that includes allowances, and read how to find the ideal run rate for the steps.
Do breaks count against OEE on a manual line?
Planned breaks are usually left out of scheduled time, but sites differ. Pick one rule and keep it, as explained in how to count breaks in OEE.
How is this different from line efficiency?
Line efficiency compares earned standard minutes with the minutes of everyone on the line, so it is a labor measure. OEE compares good output with the station's own scheduled time. See how to calculate line efficiency.
Fabrico is a light MES for OEE. It takes stops, speed and counts from PLCs or IoT sensors, with add-on AI cameras counting output where a machine has no usable signal, and operators tag the cause at the line.