Plan attainment = actual good output / planned output, as a percentage. Count it per product with over-production capped at the plan, because 400 extra units of the wrong product do not make up for 400 missing units of the right one.
What plan attainment tells you
It answers the first question a plant manager asks each morning. Did we make what we said we would make?
The number judges the promise as well as the line, since a soft plan is easy to hit. So it is most useful when read together with a measure of the line itself, such as OEE.
The formula
Use good units only, in the same unit as the plan. If your plan is in cases, count cases, and leave out anything still waiting for a quality decision.
The freeze point matters as much as the math. Compare with the plan as it stood when the period started, because a plan changed on Thursday to match the week's output will always look perfect.
Worked example: why you should cap by product
Example: a line plans three products for a week. It runs long on the easy one and falls short on the one with the difficult start-up.
| Product | Plan | Actual good | Attainment | Counted (capped) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 5,000 | 5,400 | 108% | 5,000 |
| B | 3,000 | 2,250 | 75% | 2,250 |
| C | 2,000 | 2,000 | 100% | 2,000 |
| Total | 10,000 | 9,650 | 96.5% | 9,250 = 92.5% |
A customer waiting for product B gets nothing from extra product A. Those 400 extra units also used capacity and material, and they now sit in stock.
Show both numbers if your reports already use the simple total. The gap between them is a useful sign of how much the line builds what is easy over what is due.
How to read it next to OEE
Attainment and OEE can disagree, and when they do, the disagreement is the finding. Each corner of this table points to a different kind of fix.
| Attainment | OEE | Likely reading | Where to look |
|---|---|---|---|
| High | High | Plan and line are healthy | Whether the plan could carry more |
| High | Low | The plan is built on past losses | Planning rates, and ideal cycle time |
| Low | High | Plan too heavy, or wrong products ran | Capacity and sequence |
| Low | Low | The line lost the time | The downtime Pareto |
The second row is the one people miss. A line at 100% attainment and 55% OEE has spare capacity that the plan is hiding, and that matters when sales asks for more.
A line with no orders behaves differently again, because planned time shrinks. See OEE with no orders for how to handle it.
Turn the miss into minutes
A count of missing units starts an argument, and a count of lost minutes starts a fix. Divide the shortfall by the ideal rate.
Example: product B runs at an ideal 15 units a minute, so 750 missing units equal 50 good minutes. Then look for those 50 minutes in the stop log for the B runs.
The extra A units cost time as well. At an ideal 20 units a minute, 400 units took 20 good minutes, which equals 40% of B's shortfall on its own.
When products differ a lot: use planned minutes
A piece count treats a fast product and a slow one as equals. If the ideal rates differ widely, convert the plan into good minutes and score that.
Example: A runs at 20 a minute, B at 15 and C at 10, so the plan is 250 + 200 + 200 = 650 good minutes. The capped actual is 250 + 150 + 200 = 600 minutes, which gives 92.3%.
Here the two methods nearly agree, at 92.5% and 92.3%. They drift apart when the missed product is much slower or faster than the rest, and the minutes figure is the fairer one because it shows the capacity that went unused.
Measure it often enough to act
A weekly number can only report a loss. An hourly one gives you time to recover while the shift is still running.
Plan against actual on the board. The team lead reacts when a gap opens.
What the next crew inherits, and what they must recover first.
Misses by product, with one owner per miss.
Capped attainment per line, and whether the same product keeps missing.
The hour-by-hour production board covers the first level, and short interval control explains how to run those short checks. The daily production meeting is the natural home for the third.
How attainment gets misread
- Re-planning during the period. Keep the frozen plan for the score, even if you must change the live plan.
- Counting total output. Scrap and units on hold have not met the plan.
- Letting over-plan offset under-plan. Cap per product, at least per week.
- Treating 100% as the only good result. Consistently hitting exactly 100% may mean the plan follows the line, or that people stop early.
- Mixing units across products. A total of pieces on a line with fast and slow products can hide the miss, so weigh products by their time when they differ a lot.
- Blaming the line for every miss. Code misses caused by late material or plan changes, and keep them apart. See waiting for material downtime.
Start with your constraint line
Pick your constraint line and calculate capped attainment for the last four weeks. If the same products keep missing, start with their changeovers and start-ups.
For a place to put it among other measures, see production KPIs. For the line side, how to improve OEE gives you the next step.
When a plan misses, the next question is where the minutes went. Fabrico records stops, speed and counts live from the line, and operators tag the cause at the line, so the gap has reasons next to it. See how Fabrico tracks stops and causes.
What people ask next
What is the formula for plan attainment?
Actual good output divided by planned output, as a percentage. Count it by product and cap each product at its plan, so that extra units of one product cannot hide a miss on another.
Is plan attainment the same as schedule adherence?
They are close, and plants use the names in different ways. Attainment usually asks whether the quantity was made, while adherence also asks whether it was made in the planned sequence and time window, so write down which one you report.
Can plan attainment be over 100%?
Yes, in the simple form. Treat it as a flag and not a win, because over-production uses time and material that another order may have needed.
What is a good plan attainment percentage?
It depends on how the plan is set, so a number from another plant tells you little. Look at your own trend, and read it next to OEE to see whether the plan or the line is moving.
Why is plan attainment high while OEE is low?
The plan is probably built from past output, so it already includes the losses. The line meets it easily while still running well below its ideal cycle time capability.
Fabrico is a light MES for OEE. It takes stops, speed and counts from PLCs or IoT sensors, with add-on AI cameras counting output where a machine has no usable signal, and operators tag the cause at the line.
Related guides: Plant Manager OEE KPIs: What to See Each Week · Shop Floor KPIs: What the Crew Should See · Manufacturing KPI Board: Layout That Gets Used