COPQ = internal failure cost + external failure cost. It is the money lost to scrap, rework, line holds, returns and complaints. In the example month, failure costs are EUR 32,550 out of a total cost of quality of EUR 41,550. Build the number from your own scrap, rework and returns, line by line.
What is the cost of poor quality?
The cost of poor quality (COPQ) is the money you spend because products or processes are not right the first time. It is the cost of failure: scrap, rework, returns, complaints and the time lost fixing them.
Cost of poor quality is a part of the wider cost of quality (COQ). COQ also includes what you spend to get quality: prevention and appraisal.
The common model has four categories. ASQ describes the cost of quality in these groups:
- Prevention: costs to stop defects from happening. Training, process design, FMEA, SPC.
- Appraisal: costs to find defects. Inspection, testing, gauge calibration.
- Internal failure: defects found before the product leaves the plant. Scrap, rework, re-test, line holds.
- External failure: defects found after the product leaves. Returns, warranty, complaints, recalls.
Many teams define COPQ as internal plus external failure. Some also add appraisal. Pick one and write it down.
The formula
COQ = prevention + appraisal + internal failure + external failure
Each cost line is a quantity times a cost per unit. Units scrapped x cost per unit. Hours of rework x labor rate. Returns x handling cost.
Worked example
Example: a plant looks at one month. All numbers are made up for the example.
| Cost line | Calculation | EUR |
|---|---|---|
| Internal failure | ||
| Scrap | 1,800 units x 8.00 | 14,400 |
| Rework labor | 900 units x 0.25 h x 30/h | 6,750 |
| Line holds for quality problems | 15 h x 500/h | 7,500 |
| External failure | ||
| Returns (replace, ship, handle) | 60 units x 45 | 2,700 |
| Complaint handling | 40 h x 30/h | 1,200 |
| COPQ | 28,650 + 3,900 | 32,550 |
| Appraisal: inspection labor | 180 h x 30/h | 5,400 |
| Appraisal: gauge calibration | 1,100 | |
| Prevention: SPC training, FMEA workshops | 2,500 | |
| Total cost of quality | 32,550 + 6,500 + 2,500 | 41,550 |
Failure costs are 32,550 of 41,550, or 78.3% of the total. Prevention is only 6.0% of it (2,500 / 41,550).
In this example, a lot goes to failure and little to prevention. Check whether your own split looks the same. If it does, moving some spend from failure to prevention is the first thing to test. See poka-yoke, FMEA and root cause analysis.
Rank the failures: find the biggest one
Do not attack the whole total. Split the internal failure cost by cause and rank it. In the example, the 1,800 scrapped units come from three causes:
| Cause of scrap | Units | EUR at 8.00 each | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dimension out of tolerance | 770 | 6,160 | 42.8% |
| Seal leak | 620 | 4,960 | 34.4% |
| Label misprint | 410 | 3,280 | 22.8% |
| Total | 1,800 | 14,400 | 100% |
The 8.00 per unit comes from 4.50 of material, 2.00 of labor and 1.50 of machine time (example numbers). Two causes make up 77.2% of the scrap cost. Fix those first. A Pareto chart makes this obvious. See the downtime Pareto chart, which works the same way for defects.
If one cause is a machine setting, the fix may cost nothing. If it is a supplier problem, the cost can be charged back. Either way, the number gives you a reason to act and a way to check later that you did.
How to show COPQ to management
Keep it to one page. Show the four categories as a bar chart, the top three causes and the trend over the last six months. Write the definition in a line at the bottom.
Add one action per top cause with an owner and a date. A number without an owner will not move.
How COPQ links to OEE
The scrap line above prices machine time at cost (1.50 a unit). But the time itself matters too. At an ideal rate of 600 units an hour, 1,800 scrapped units used 1,800 / 600 = 3.0 machine hours that made nothing sellable. In OEE this is the quality loss, which Overall Equipment Effectiveness (R. C. Hansen, 2001) calls waste. It is counted in units and converted to time at the ideal rate.
If that machine is the bottleneck, those 3.0 hours also cost you the sales you could have made. That is the number most COPQ sheets miss.
Hansen also ranks "negative runtime" as the worst kind of loss. It is when you run for hours without knowing the product is bad. By the time you find it, the whole run is scrap. This is why prevention and early detection pay.
Put the two views side by side. OEE quality loss shows the time. COPQ shows the money. See how to calculate scrap rate and the scrap rate calculator.
How to measure it on the floor
- List the failure types. Scrap, rework, line holds, returns, complaints.
- Count the quantity of each. Use the scrap bin, the rework log and the returns record.
- Price each one. Use material, labor and machine cost. Ask finance for the rates.
- Add them up monthly. Keep the same lines each month so the trend is clear.
- Add the quality-related stops and the OEE waste. Use the stop log, see how to track downtime.
Hidden costs most sheets miss
- Extra machine time on the bottleneck, as above.
- Expediting. Rush orders to cover scrapped units.
- Extra inventory kept as a buffer against bad units.
- Lost customers and the time to rebuild trust. This is hard to price. Say so instead of guessing.
We do not give a "typical COPQ as a percent of sales" here. A figure like that needs a source and your own mix of products. Build your own number from your own lines, as above.
Common mistakes
- Counting only scrap. Rework and line holds are often bigger.
- Mixing categories. Do not count the same inspection hours as both appraisal and failure.
- Pricing at material cost only. Add labor and machine time.
- Changing the lines every month. You lose the trend.
- Hiding structural waste. Hansen warns that companies often hide the scrap that is built into the normal process. Show it.
Scrap and quality stops cost machine time as well as material. Fabrico is a light MES for OEE that shows counts, stops and OEE per line and shift, so you can price the time you lose. See how Fabrico shows OEE per line and shift.
What people ask next
What is the difference between COPQ and COQ?
COQ is the full cost of quality: prevention, appraisal and failure. COPQ is the failure part, internal plus external. Some teams add appraisal to COPQ. State your definition.
What is included in internal failure costs?
Costs of defects found before shipping: scrap, rework, re-inspection, line holds and downtime caused by quality problems. In OEE terms, scrap is the waste loss and quality stops are DT Quality in the Hansen scheme.
How do I find the cost of scrap?
Multiply scrapped units by the full cost of a unit up to the point it was scrapped: material, labor and machine time. Add the disposal cost. Use the scrap rate calculator for the rate itself.
How can I lower my cost of poor quality?
Find the biggest failure line and fix its cause. Move some spend to prevention, such as mistake-proofing and process checks. See how to reduce scrap and rework.
How does COPQ relate to first pass yield?
Each unit that does not pass first time creates failure cost. A low first-pass yield means a high COPQ. See rolled throughput yield and how to calculate first pass yield.
Fabrico is a light MES for OEE. It takes stops, speed and counts from PLCs or IoT sensors, with add-on AI cameras counting output where a machine has no usable signal, and operators tag the cause at the line.
Related guides: MES vs SPC: A System and a Statistical Method